NOMISMA

Money That Is No Longer Used

There are four patterns for when a currency ceases to serve its role. The market refuses to accept it, it is abolished by decree, it becomes void after defeat in war, and it falls out of use even though no one has forbidden it.

Time to read the text: about 10 min
The review questions are optional and not included in this time.
What you can read: the course opening and contents are free; the full text is for those who have purchased
After purchase, you can read the full text once your access starts.

Disappeared Money in 3 Minutes

  1. See it
  2. In numbers
  3. What would you do?
  4. Read more

1See it

Swipe to see more

1 / 9

Money disappears in four ways: it's rejected, abolished, defeated, or it fades away.

For money, disappearing is a normal part of life.

2 / 9

1344, England

The king's gold coins were valued too high, so the market wouldn't take them.

They were recalled in a few months. No one had banned them.

3 / 9

1670, Japan

The shogunate government banned all coins except the Kan'ei Tsūhō.

They banned the old coins only after putting enough good new ones into circulation.

4 / 9

September 1945, Netherlands

All banknotes were made invalid. People were left with a single new 10-guilder note.

The money wasn't confiscated. It was replaced with bank deposits and new notes.

5 / 9

November 8, 2016, India

A TV announcement made two high-value banknotes invalid overnight.

Over 80%

The share of all circulating money that turned into plain paper overnight.

6 / 9

5th century, Britain

The government system for paying salaries disappeared, and money quietly fell out of use.

No one banned it.

7 / 9

1936, Spain

During the civil war, money with the same name split in two.

In 1939, the notes from the losing side were made invalid.

8 / 9

Medieval Germany

Coins were exchanged at set times. 4 old coins were swapped for 3 new ones.

Money that lost value just by holding on to it.

9 / 9

1917, Soviet Union

Even the country that tried to abolish money ended up using it to rebuild.

Even powerful ideals couldn't get rid of money.

2In numbers

Over 80%

The percentage of circulating money in India that became worthless paper overnight in 2016.

70years

How long the Soviet Union's experiment to put money 'to sleep' lasted.

3What would you do?

It's 1344 in England. Someone offers to pay you with the king's new gold coin. But it's overvalued compared to silver. What do you do?

Pick one

Accept it at face value.

Accepting it at face value meant you would lose money on the deal.

Don't accept it.

People quietly refused them. The coins were recalled and abolished just a few months after they were issued. There were no riots or protests.

4Read more

Read the full story ↓

ReconstructionMoney That Is No Longer Used — course frontispiece

What you will understand after this course

  • You can tell apart the four types of a currency's disappearance, with examples.
  • You can explain a case of disappearance by market refusal, apart from the strength of power.
  • You can explain why annulment by decree tends to be told as "confiscation."
More about this course

Course number: B16

Supervised by: Mitsuru Hayama

Beyond the text: 11 exercises · 4 coins · 17 readings · 1 references How reading times are calculated

You will also understand

  • You can state, in your own words, the conditions under which money vanishes although no one banned it.
  • Can explain, with actual examples, the fragmentation of currency due to civil war and partition, and the pattern of resolution by the victor.
  • Can explain the mechanism and objective of *Verrufung* (periodic renewal of coinage).

You can start this course without reading any other course.

Also worth reading, to see the connections (optional)

If you want to know more about checking sources (optional)

Assessment

11 exercises in this course (8 check, 0 compare, 3 written). Progress is recorded by self-assessment.

The 8 chapters of this course
  1. Disappearance happens in every countryDisappearance is not an accident but an ordinary event; every edition has examples. But counts also mirror the writer's interest.
  2. If the market does not accept it, even the king's gold coin will not circulate.A coin refused by the market vanishes without anyone banning it. The receiver decides, not the issuer.
  3. Abolition by Edict — The Day It Becomes Invalid OvernightA decree can void money. But the length of grace changes the outcome. Write the design and the experience apart.
  4. Ceasing to Be Used, Though No One Forbids ItThere is extinction without an actor. If the system that requires money disappears, it will cease to be used without being forbidden by anyone.
  5. Splitting Currencies — Civil War and DivisionWhen a battlefront divides a nation, its currency also splits. The outcome is decided by the victor's decree.
  6. Currency That Periodically Dies — VerrufungA currency that lost value just by being held—effectively penalizing hoarding—actually existed in medieval Germany.
  7. The Dream of Abolition — An Experiment to Eliminate MoneyThe revolutionary regime even dreamed of abolishing money. The seventy-year experiment came to a close along with the empire.
  8. The Afterlife — Names, Promises, and CollectiblesA currency lives on after its death in three forms: in names, in promises of exchange, and as collectibles.
Readings (17)
  • The gold coin that failed Britain 1344 The London mint
    §2. A gold coin refused by the market. It was over in a few months.
  • Berlin, the border between east and west Germany The blockade and the two marks 1948–1949
    §2. Check the gap between the official ratio and the black-market rate.
  • The realm of three coinages Japan 1668–1670 Kameido village, Edo
    §3. Note what was done before the prohibition.
  • A liberated town, the ration counter Netherlands The week of the ten-guilder note September 1945
    §3. The scene of living a week on a single note.
  • A bank counter, the autumn of declarations Netherlands The week of the ten-guilder note 1945
    §3. ⚠ A correction of the way it is told as "confiscation." This is the core of the course.
  • Japan Overview: the world AD 1946 The New Yen Conversion
    §3. The same method was applied in Japan too.
  • India Overview: the world AD 2016 Demonetisation
    §3. What happens when the grace period is a single night.
  • The border with the Soviet occupation zone Germany The blockade and the two marks 1948
    §3. A case where the split of the currency preceded the split of the state.
  • The peninsula torn in two Spain The civil war 1936
    The other side of §3. Holding the enemy's notes became a crime.
  • The peninsula after the war Spain The civil war 1939
    The other side of §3. The fate that awaits the loser's money.
  • The island where money vanished Britain the 5th century A provincial town falling into decay
    §4. A disappearance with no agent. This is the conclusion of the course.
  • Russia Overview: the world from AD 1917 The Experiment That Put Money to Sleep
    §4. An experiment that set out to abolish money and ended by remaking it.
  • The bracteate Germany the 12th–13th centuries The market square of a territory
    Section 6. A currency penalized for hoarding. The full text of the law that overturns modern common sense.
  • Towards the euro Spain the present Madrid, the Puerta del Sol
    Section 8. Posthumous life in a name. The concluding paragraph of the chapter.
  • Notes that promise no exchange China the 15th–17th centuries Face values that survive only in ledgers
    Alive in law, but dead in the market. This describes a banknote that remained unchanged for two hundred years without causing major disruption, and the reason why it was more peaceful not to abolish it.
  • Ten to One South Korea 1962 The Exchange Counter
    This is the record of a currency conversion designed to draw out hoarded cash that failed to achieve its goal. The central bank itself has left a written account of this.
  • Platinum Coinage Russia 1845 Saint Petersburg
    This is the story of a platinum coin after it was demonetized in seventeen years. It describes where the metal went after many of the recalled coins were melted down and ceased to be currency.
References

The books and materials referred to in this course.

Read next

Considering "Bad money drives out good" →

What you learn next: You can say, with grounds, whose words the so-called Gresham's law actually are.

Time to read the text: about 8 min / What you can read: the course opening and contents are free; the full text is for those who have purchased

Price

After purchase, the full courses, the illustrated books, every country’s story and the numismatics examination are open to you.

See the price →