NOMISMA

When the Credit of Paper Money Collapsed

What happened before paper money fell out of use? We will examine the decisions of those who tried to support the system.

Time to read the text: about 8 min
The review questions are optional and not included in this time.
What you can read: the course opening and contents are free; the full text is for those who have purchased
After purchase, you can read the full text once your access starts.

When Paper Money Goes Up in Flames: A 3-Minute Guide

  1. See it
  2. In numbers
  3. What would you do?
  4. Read more

1See it

Swipe to see more

1 / 9

13th Century

The Yuan emperor made paper money the only currency in the country.

Just plain paper was accepted with the same value as gold.

2 / 9

When the country's finances got tight, they printed more paper money.

This was after it had worked splendidly for nearly 100 years.

3 / 9

1720

In Paris, paper money printed to prop up stocks collapsed.

The memory of this collapse didn't prevent the next failure.

4 / 9

January 1923

Wages for striking workers were paid with the printing press.

Foreign troops had entered the industrial region.

5 / 9

November 1923

Prices rose twice a day; a price in the morning was different by the evening.

4,200,000,000,000 marks

The official rate for 1 dollar.

6 / 9

November 15, 1923

A new currency, the Rentenmark, quietly appeared.

1 = 1,000,000,000,000

Exchanged for 1,000,000,000,000 old marks.

7 / 9

What worked was the promise: 'We won't print any more.'

The paper that burned and the paper that stood tall were physically the same.

8 / 9

2008

In Zimbabwe, the fire broke out again.

Annual price increases in the trillions of billions.

9 / 9

Separating the role of printing money from the state, and publicly setting an inflation target.

Today's firewalls, born from the memory of pain.

2In numbers

15hours

The time it took for prices to double in Hungary in 1946.

1trillion marks

The amount of old paper marks exchanged for 1 new note.

3What would you do?

You are living in Germany in the autumn of 1923. A new paper currency has been issued. It looks the same as the old one: just printed paper. What do you do?

Pick one

It's just paper, so I don't trust it.

The burned Mark and the standing Rentenmark were physically the same paper. What made the difference wasn't the paper, but the promise.

I'll use it if I can believe the promise 'no more printing'.

And that's what actually happened. Issuance was limited, and the government's magic money hammer was taken away. The moment people believed it, the paper became money again.

4Read more

Read the full story ↓

ReconstructionWhen the Credit of Paper Money Collapsed — course frontispiece

What you will understand after this course

  • You can explain what was actually lost when paper money lost its value.
  • You can explain the mechanism of over-printing from the government's own circumstances.
  • You can explain why the Rentenmark worked, separating the collateral from the promise.
More about this course

Course number: C12

Supervised by: Mitsuru Hayama

Beyond the text: 11 exercises · 5 coins · 15 readings · 1 references How reading times are calculated

You will also understand

  • You can say why the same shape recurred over seven hundred years.
  • Can explain the failure of the Mandats territoriaux as a "second piece of paper" structure.
  • Can compare the post-war currency reforms (Lieftinck, Shin-en) as a "prescription of drastic medicine".

You can start this course without reading any other course.

Also worth reading, to see the connections (optional)

If you want to know more about checking sources (optional)

Assessment

11 exercises in this course (7 check, 1 compare, 3 written). Progress is recorded by self-assessment.

The 8 chapters of this course
  1. The first to burn was ChinaThe notes worked a hundred years before they burned. Paper burns not by its material but when the printer's circumstances change.
  2. The second time was ParisThe paper printed to prop up the shares collapsed. And the memory of collapse does not prevent the next one.
  3. The year the press became a weaponOver-printing is not the cause but the middle. Without asking why they had to print, you cannot see how to stop.
  4. How to put out the fire — not with goods, with a promiseWhat holds paper up is not goods but a promise. And what burns is not the paper but the promise.
  5. The Ceremony of Burning the Tools — Failure of the Second PaperEven after burning the printing plates in public, the second paper currency plummeted from day one. A ceremony cannot create credit.
  6. A Drastic Prescription — Lieftinck and the New YenInvalidation of all banknotes and freezing of deposits. One week on a single ten-guilder note. The post-war settlement was carried out in a person's name.
  7. The Astronomical Country — Zimbabwe and the Return of the FireAn annual rate of a hundred million trillion. A thousand years after the first fire, these conflagrations are still not a thing of the past.
  8. Preventing the Fire — The Firewall of IndependenceSeparate issuance from the government and set a target for prices. This is the current fire prevention design, a lesson humanity learned from fires.
Readings (15)
  • Yuan · Dadu Overview: the world The monetary civilisation of the East AD 1260
    §1. The scene where an economy of paper alone appears.
  • The Runaway Jiaochao Overview: the world The monetary civilisation of the East AD 1287
    §1. Its end. ⚠ Do not read it as "because it was paper."
  • Rue Vivienne, Paris France John Law's bubble 1716–1719
    §2. The scene where Law founds his bank.
  • The Banque Royale, Paris France John Law's bubble 1720
    §2. It explains why the system collapsed.
  • France under Louis XV France John Law's bubble 1720–1789
    §2. The long distrust of paper that remained after the collapse.
  • The occupation of the Ruhr Germany 1923 Berlin, the banknote printing works
    §3. The centre of this course. It is written why they printed.
  • The autumn of 1923 Germany the autumn of 1923 A street corner, the way to the shops
    §3. The photograph of the handcart. ⚠ Consider also what the photograph does not show.
  • The farmland and factories of Germany Germany The miracle of the Rentenmark 15 November 1923
    §4. The strangeness of the collateral being land.
  • The morning market, the new paper Germany The miracle of the Rentenmark 1923–1924
    §4. The revelation: it was not goods but a promise.
  • The Pengő, the Worst in History Overview: the world A history of inflation AD 1946
    §4. The worst record in history. The names for the numbers run out.
  • The paper they printed too much of France 1796–1797 Place Vendôme, Paris
    Section 5. Trust Cannot Be Created by Ritual. The Record on the Second Sheet of Paper.
  • The week of the ten-guilder note Netherlands September 1945 A liberated town, the ration counter
    Section 6. A Week with a Single Ten-Gulden Note. The Name Left on the Drastic Remedy.
  • The Hundred-Trillion-Dollar Note Overview: the world A history of inflation AD 2008
    Section 7. Fire Is Not Yet a Thing of the Past.
  • Vaccination Overview: the world A history of inflation the present day
    Section 8. The Blueprint Humanity Learned from a Thousand Years of Fires.
  • Only gold coins are the yardstick Greece October 1944 A laboratory for posterity
    This stop re-measures the magnitude of the "fire" using three yardsticks: speed, position in the classics, and duration. After seeing how the rankings change with each yardstick, please re-read the "worst in history" sections of other stops.
References
  • Inflation – lessons learnt from history — Deutsche Bundesbank The hyperinflation of 1923. The currency ceased to function as a means of payment and store of value, and was replaced by the Rentenmark in November 1923.

The books and materials referred to in this course.

Read next

Money, Read Through Events →

What you learn next: To be able to read a single incident from its first scene to the end, and to explain in your own words what happened, why it spread, and how it reached everyday life.

Time to read the text: about 7 min / What you can read: the course opening and contents are free; the full text is for those who have purchased

Price

After purchase, the full courses, the illustrated books, every country’s story and the numismatics examination are open to you.

See the price →