A Kingdom That Created Wealth with Paper, and Was Burned by Paper
A gambler who stabbed a man in a duel and was sentenced to death took control of France's finances. His idea that increasing paper money would stimulate the economy threw the country into a frenzy, eventually leaving long-lasting after-effects.
The Frenzy of Rue Quincampoix
Paris's Rue Quincampoix was originally an open-air market in a narrow alley where discounted government bonds were traded. In 1719, it became the center of a frenzy. A share with a face value of 500 livres soared to 1,000 in July, 3,600 in August, and 5,350 in September. The peak was approximately 10,000 livres—a twentyfold increase.
It is said that the word "millionaire" was coined at this time to refer to those who became rich overnight, but its first appearance has not been confirmed. Stories of servants and coachmen rising to wealth are also without foundation, and no such examples are found in contemporary records. Nevertheless, the wealth that existed there was certainly a wealth counted in paper.
The Gambler's Grand Scheme
The mastermind was the Scottish-born John Law. A skilled gambler well-versed in probability, he had a past in London where he stabbed a man in a duel, was sentenced to death, and fled to the continent. He argued that paper money was superior to metal and that increasing its supply would stimulate the economy.
In a France whose finances were ruined by war expenses, the Regent, the Duke of Orléans, placed his bet on Law. In 1716, the Banque Générale was established, and two years later it became the Banque Royale with state backing. The banknotes could also be used to pay taxes. Law went further in 1717, founding the Western Company, which aimed to monopolize the Mississippi River basin. The heart of this scheme was a debt-for-equity swap, allowing the company's shares to be purchased with nearly worthless government bonds. He converted the national debt into shares and supported it with banknotes. The company swallowed everything from the tobacco monopoly to tax collection, taking control of both colonial trade and the nation's finances.
Paper Wealth Detached from Reality
The foundation of the company's wealth was not the colonies. By the end of 1718, only twelve ships had set sail. The source of its wealth was loans to the king and taxes. The gap between the reality of a swampy Louisiana and the wealth on paper only widened. It was a wealth that was created, and at the same time, a wealth destined to be burned.
The logic of the collapse was simple. Far more paper was printed than the amount of metal available for conversion. The balance of banknotes at the end of May 1720 was 2,235,010,000 livres. In contrast, contemporary estimates placed the amount of specie in the country at about 1.2 billion.
Collapsed Confidence, and What Remained
On May 21, 1720, the state issued a decree to devalue the notes and shares monthly. This was tantamount to the state itself admitting the depreciation of its paper, and confidence collapsed. People rushed to the bank demanding gold coins, and some were crushed in the stampede. Law, who had been appointed Controller-General of Finances in January of that year, fled the country in early December.
After Law's bubble burst, France was left with long-lasting after-effects. The attempt to replace specie with paper was long held in disrepute. In 1726, the currency returned to metal. The weights of the Louis d'or and the écu were firmly fixed, and this stability lasted for about sixty to seventy years, until the Revolution.
More in Topics in money
The Indemnity That Never Reached Japan
The indemnity from the First Sino-Japanese War was a colossal sum, more than four times Japan's annual revenue. However, this money was never transported to Japan; it was received in London as a figure in a ledger.
Who Financed the Meiji Restoration?
In the seventh year of the Ansei era, in an Edo where the Great Elder had been assassinated, the smallest koban in Japan was born. In this year, when political upheaval and currency debasement coincided, both the anti-shogunate and pro-shogunate forces needed money for their respective struggles. Where did that money come from?
Coins of Different Faces, but the Same Weight
An emperor of France, a king of Belgium, a goddess of Switzerland. Coins bearing different faces, words, and country names on one side circulated at equal value across borders. There was only one promise.
If you would like to read on
Everything in these pieces comes from the material itself.